Is a Tax Residency Certificate sufficient to claim treaty benefits?
A TRC from the recipient's home jurisdiction is necessary but not sufficient. The full documentation typically required includes the TRC, Form 41 (Form 10F) (self-certification of treaty applicability), the No-PE declaration where applicable, and the underlying contract supporting payment classification. The Income Tax Department also retains the right to assess commercial substance, particularly for intermediate holding jurisdictions, under the GAAR framework.
What is the typical timeline for Form 15CB issuance?
For a routine cross-border remittance with complete documentation, Form 15CB issuance is typically 2 to 3 working days from instructions. Complex transactions (royalties with transfer pricing dimensions, intermediate jurisdiction holdings, novel payment structures) may take 5 to 10 working days, including the position memorandum supporting the certificate. Form 15CA is filed by the remitter (or by us on the remitter's behalf) following the 15CB issuance.
Does India have a tax treaty with my country?
India has DTAAs with over 90 jurisdictions including the US, UK, Singapore, UAE, Canada, Australia, Germany, France, Netherlands, Switzerland, Mauritius, Cyprus, Ireland, Luxembourg, Malta, and most major economies. The DTAA framework varies materially across treaties. Our position memorandum for any specific transaction covers the applicable treaty with the specific article references.
What is the difference between Form 15CA and Form 15CB?
Form 15CB is the Chartered Accountant's certificate certifying the tax position on a foreign remittance, including the nature of the payment, applicable tax treaty rate, and TDS compliance. Form 15CA is the remitter's declaration filed with the Income Tax Department in electronic form, typically accompanied by the Form 15CB. For remittances below certain thresholds or specified exempt categories, the requirements may be relaxed.
How is the equalisation levy different from Section 195 TDS?
Only one equalisation levy remains in force: a 6% charge on specified digital advertising services (the Google/Meta-style ad-spend levy), borne directly by the Indian payer rather than withheld from the non-resident. The broader 2% levy on e-commerce supply or services was withdrawn effective 1 August 2024 (Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024) — a payment made on or after that date is no longer subject to it, though the underlying Section 195 withholding position (or its absence, where there is no PE) is unaffected by the levy's withdrawal. Unlike Section 195 TDS, the surviving 6% levy is a direct liability of the Indian payer, not a withholding mechanism, and is in addition to (not in lieu of) any income tax obligation.
Does Advisory Monks Consulting coordinate with US CPAs for US person advisory?
Yes. Integrated India-US tax advisory typically requires coordinated work between an Indian Chartered Accountant (covering the India-side position) and a US CPA (covering the US-side position). Our practice operates routinely with US CPAs, and where the client does not have one, we can introduce qualified partners through our Global desk.
What's the reporting deadline after an outbound ODI investment, and what happens if it's missed?
The Indian entity must report the investment — via Form FC under the Overseas Investment Rules, 2022 — within 30 days of the transaction, and then file an Annual Performance Report for the overseas entity every year by 31 December. Missing the initial 30-day window doesn't void the investment, but it moves the filing into RBI's compounding process: a formal application, an admitted contravention, and a compounding fee scaled to the amount and the delay — a manageable but entirely avoidable cost if the filing is calendared from day one.
Can an Indian company claim foreign tax credit for withholding by a country with no DTAA with India?
Yes, though the mechanism is different from a treaty claim. Where no DTAA exists, relief is available under Section 91 of the Income-tax Act — India's unilateral relief provision — rather than a treaty's foreign tax credit article, generally capped at the lower of the foreign tax paid or the Indian tax payable on that income, computed income-item by income-item rather than treaty-article by treaty-article. Documentation mirrors the treaty case: proof of the foreign tax actually paid, filed via Form 67 alongside the Indian return.
Is Form 3CEB required even when related-party transaction value is below the specified threshold?
Form 3CEB itself has no separate value threshold — if a taxpayer has any international transaction or specified domestic transaction with an associated enterprise during the year, an accountant's report in Form 3CEB is required, regardless of size. What the specified thresholds actually govern is the depth of contemporaneous transfer pricing documentation required, and eligibility for Safe Harbour — a small transaction can still need Form 3CEB filed, just with lighter supporting documentation behind it.
What documentation supports a beneficial-ownership claim for reduced treaty dividend withholding?
Beneficial ownership isn't self-certified by the TRC alone — the payer and the Assessing Officer look for evidence that the recipient entity has genuine economic substance and discretion over the income, not just legal title passing through. In practice that means board minutes showing independent decision-making on the funds, no contractual or practical obligation to pass the income to a third party, adequate local staff and office presence relative to its function, and real economic risk rather than a conduit role. A TRC and Form 41 (Form 10F) remain necessary, but for larger dividend flows through an intermediate holding jurisdiction, the substance file is often what actually decides the position on audit.
Does an Indian startup need to register for Equalisation Levy on payments to a foreign SaaS vendor?
Not for the SaaS payment itself, in most cases — the 2% levy that would have covered e-commerce and digital services was withdrawn effective 1 August 2024. The surviving 6% levy applies specifically to digital advertising spend, not general SaaS subscriptions. Since this area has moved twice in recent Finance Acts, confirm the current position against the payment date rather than assuming last year's treatment still applies.
How does POEM risk apply to a foreign subsidiary managed day-to-day from India?
If a foreign subsidiary's key management and commercial decisions are, in substance, made in India rather than at its nominal offshore board, it risks being treated as an Indian tax resident under POEM (Place of Effective Management) and taxed here on its worldwide income — the opposite of what an offshore structure is usually built to achieve. The common failure pattern is a founder who relocates to India while continuing to run a Singapore or Delaware entity from Bengaluru: board meetings held on paper offshore, real decisions made over calls from India. The defence is documented substance — genuine board deliberation and minutes at the offshore location, local directors with real authority, and decisions that demonstrably happen where the paperwork says they happen.